“Do you consider what you’ve written a serious response? I can’t tell”
Well this is a silly discussion
There is no need for a Rav, and if the Rav gets it wrong there is no excuse to violate a LAv and say the Rav told me too
As I posted before
It is quite simple:
I have a simple question for the OP:
Do you think somebody MIGHT be in danger?
There are three possible answers:
1) Yes (this is how I understood the OP)
definitely call the police. (Is there anyone, besides for Joseph, who disagrees in this situation?)
2) No – (I dont see how this fits with the OP)
I agree dont call the police. IF there is no chance anyone is in danger
3) I dont know
This response shows a misunderstanding of the the question was “MIGHT someone be in danger” if you dont know then the answer is Yes. See above for the appropriate action
LU
“I think that you were talking about different situations than I was.”
the situationis where yo udont know (see above)
If you see smoke dont know what it is (and cant investiagte for whatever reason) what do you do?
It is the same here. as you correctly pointed out.