Thanks for clarifying yytz
I suspected you didnt mena what literally what you wrote.
Joseph as I said youve created a strawman. Nobody here says it is “OK” for him to remian intermarried.
The question is should we try to be mekarev him anyway and at least get what we can.
Gaon,
“allow me to elaborate, when it comes to ultra-sensitive issues as Ishus and Yichus. There is no definite p’sak or procedure and, cannot be, as the Geirus is entirely up to B’D, and these cases need guidance of Gedola Horaha, due to the gravity of the issue ruled as a case-by-case basis…”
Agreed completely, as I said “Of course it depends, again Im sorry if I implied there is any blanket statment for such complicated issues.”