Reply To: Are all these protests in Jerusalem really a kiddush hashem?

Joseph – those are only false strawmen if:
a. they are false facts and
b. you don’t expect that the gedolim who told them to protest are not capable of being ro’eh es hanolad.
But those stories are true: they attacked, pushed, and spit on women. They blocked traffic causing untold gezel zman, not to mention Stam gezeilah.
And gedolim are Chachomim. Aizehu Chochom? HaRo’eh es haNolad.
I leave it to the smart people in this coffee room to complete the syllogism and draw the correct conclusion.