Reply To: Artscroll Shas – English vs. Hebrew editions

Home Forums Seforim, Books, & Reading Artscroll Shas – English vs. Hebrew editions Reply To: Artscroll Shas – English vs. Hebrew editions

#1429555
iacisrmma
Participant

“would not be caught dead seen using the English Artscroll”

Are you referring to chachamim here in the US or EY? The chachmim in the US may not need the English version and fell more comfortable with the Hebrew version. Don’t try to denigrate them with such an outlandish comment when those like R’ Dovid Feinstein have been quoted as saying that there is nothing wrong with looking at the ArtScroll elucidation for poshut pshat and then breaking your head on RASHI and TOSFOS.

Please remember that it was the gedolim of the previous generation (including R’ Yaakov Kaminetsky TZATZAL and R’ Mordechai Gifter TZATZAL) that guided and encouraged R’ Meir Zlotowitz TZTZAL an YBLCH R’ Nosson Scherman to produce the English version.