Me12345:
You wrote: “Takes2 that’s a big shaila in halacha if you’re supposed to answer about smoking. ” Can you please tell me where this shailoh is found? I need a single reference (or more) in a reputable sefer that considers this as a question. Smoking, according somewhere around 95% plus of poskim consider this an issur d’Oraysa. Secondly, smoking implies an aspect of self pleasure that easily affects others adversely (in stinking and second hand smoke). Thirdly, there are health risks that significantly increase the possibility of chronic disease and early death. Someone who asks about this is entitled to an honest answer, and I cannot believe that anyone who is considered a posek says that there is a question about this. To me, there is zero shailoh. Who (poskim please) think there is a question?