NevilleChaimBerlin,
I may be mistaken but it seems to me that you are advocating killing them all out, or keeping them stateless under Israeli military control indefinitely. There is no place for them to go (in spite of the wishes of people like Avik & CS no other country will take them) and your definitely not advocating making them full citizens of Israel (something that Israel has never put on the table in either case).
Advocating the killing of 4 million people, men, women and children is thankfully an extreme minority position even among the most right wing religious Zionists. Its a hard position to defend from a moral perspective. I don’t think one really needs to say much to see why this is so.
Keeping them stateless under military control is just not possible forever (besides for being morally wrong and not fair, shouldn’t the people who live in a land have a say as to how they are governed?)
So without getting all hyperbolic and accusing anyone of antisemitism can you either defend one of these positions as moral and fair or explain another option that I am not seeing.