Chossid on my “criteria”: “Again making up criterias.”
100%. It is what I, and I alone, expect from a gadol beYisroel. Who makes up your criteria? Seriously.
“And btw do you have clue what’s going on in ponivich? Everyone still calls them godel beyisrael.”
Everyone. You forget that I’m not a Litvak.
Rso: “5. He doesn’t think about promoting himself.”
Cool to see that you have ruach hakodesh, and know what’s going on in his mind. (And why don’t you say the same thing about shach?)”
No ruach hakodesh. But every frum Yid decides for themselves who is a gadol beYisrael. Some might use criteria given by others, but in the end each Yid decides which criteria to use. Just as you chose to believe whatever your rebbe says. It’s YOU choosing to do that. No one is forcing you.
So even though I don’t KNOW what’s going on in “his mind” I have to judge by what I see. And that’s the way I see it.
And in reply to saying the same thing about Rav Shach. You don’t know what I think of him because I haven’t discussed him, so please don’t assume.
“Again these are all made up criterias by a little pipsqueak”
Yep. This pipsqueak is making criteria (there is no such word as criterias, as criteria is already the plural) to determine what this pipsqueak should believe. As I wrote above you can decide on your own criteria for your far more brilliant mind.