Reply To: Joining Chabad

Home › Forums › Rants › Joining Chabad › Reply To: Joining Chabad

#1706155
Anyusernameopen?
Participant

@rso
1 a. When you have an argument with someone your supposed to argue on the same thing –
I think I said 3 times about the abarbanel and you keep arguing on a diff point that I never brought up.
b. Just to make it simple since anything i say you will disagree with so I’ll just quote from the artscroll which I assume everyone here holds of
“Begining of Footnote 42: If the Messiah is currently alive, he is certainly Rebbi. If the Messiah is someone who has a ready died, he is Daniel. (Abarbanel explains that it is possible for the Messiah to be among the resurrected (Yeshuos Meshicho lyun 2 ch. 1).)”
the abarbanel says nothing about being doniel rather about being from the dead
The point is that there are opinions that say moshiach can come from the dead.

2 let me make this a little bit simpler (the supposed term)
??? ??? ??? ??? ???? ?”? ??? ????? ??? ???? (????”? ???? ?”? ?????? ????”?? ?????? ????????”?

How I think it’s translated
In every generation there is someone capable of being moshiach in case the yidden are meritus/???? (or ??? however you want to translate this)
Based on this this, the talmidim of the arizal wrote that in the days of the arizal it was the arizal.

What I take from this is that they assumed that moshiach is the greatest person in that generation and they said Who is greater then the a arizal – if they felt there was someone greater then the arizal they would have said that it was that person

= I think the rebbe is the greatest person in our generation so if I’m looking for a candidate for moshiach I think that it should be him – the greatest person in our generation.

You on the other hand are not a lubavicher so you think that someone else was greater then the rebbe I’m ok with that -everyone has there own opinion. So I would assume that you say that that person is moshiach.