Reply To: Eggs: chumra to treat then like fleishig

Is adding a chumra distorting or mocking halacha?

I am open to hearing and accepting if you can back it with sources – like I do.

Do you not have any chumros?

Do you disagree with Ramban that it is a mitzva to add chumros?

Do you think the Mesilas Yeshorim is distorting and mocking halacha by telling us that perishus by adding chumros is good?

Do you have a source that eggs are paraveh and if so one must NOT treat them as fleishig?

Chazal gave a HETER to eat honey – because it is produced seperate from the bee. That implies that eggs would be part of chicken.

Chazal use a possuk to show that milk is not meat – because the Torah prohibits eating/cooking meat with milk. Implying, without the possuk, milk would be meat. Applying to eggs, where there is no possuk, eggs would be fleishig.

I stress, as a chumrah, not “midina” (halacha) but as a stringency.

Do you have sources that eggs are parave? – bring them! But making up “halacha” without sources is in itself a mockery and distortion which you commit.