Reply To: Do I owe my neighbor kosher meat or treif meat?

David Y:
She is frum and Jewish.
She bought treif meat for her dog (at $0.59 a lb).
She now wants a lb of the kosher meat from my pot which she can feed her family (and worth $4.99/lb).
True one of the lbs of meat in my pot are hers – as she claims.
But she deposited treif meat – so I say she gets only treif meat.
She says no, her treif meat is now kosher meat.
There is no other issue here except:
Does she get a lb of treif meat at $0.59/lb or kosher meat worth $4.99/lb (- chassidishe shchita, no less)?
That is the dilemma.