Reply To: Waiter’s finger was in my my soup!

“The Rashba and the Ritvah opine,like the Ramban, that it is permitted to eat human meat.” Yeah um this is pure am haaratzos, since without question it is assur for a Jew to have haanah from a mes. So no they do not hold it is permitted to eat human meat. Though they do hold it isnt included in a specific issur.

You mix up d’oraysa (which they hold there is no issur min haTorah) with d’rabbonon. You also mix up the d’rabbonon for a Jew with a goy – who has no issur at all.

You need to sort yourself out and unconfuse yourself before calling names of “am haaretz” to others that know what they are saying. Helpful hint: At the very least look up the seforim that were cited with marei mekomos before forming an opinion and putting down others that actually learned the sugya in depth.