“However In heaven, they can and do judge based on grama as well, ”
Yes!
So is it impossible to beleive that in shomayim they punish a rapist worse than a thief?
Clearly you agree that IS the fact that the punishment is lighter by beis din is not the be all end all in determining severity
“surely you agree the poor person who stole to feed his family did a “lower averia” than the rich person who stole to spite the poor man
.No. I don’t. Stealing is stealing.”
nu nu its a machloikes you and Dovid Hamelech
“A king has the right to extra curricular judgmental leeway.
So David hamelech could also punish for intent.”
Again, WHY would he punished for intent? IF the “stealing is stealing” who cares about intent?
Does intent make the act worse yes or no? I cant follow your position
“Ask your rav please to explain please the following”
Are you quoting something? I cant find that online anywhere
SO forcing an eishes is h is worse than a besulah. what does that prove
And are you forgetting the story ? she introduced herself as his siter it wasnt a case of nenas in the classical sense as far as I’m aware
And even if it was, what does this prove that Avimelech doesnt hink rape is bad either. Shkoyach your in good company
As you may know shechem was punished SEVERELY for his act so I’m not sure what you are proving