“�So you Ubiq, BOTH AGREE AND DISAGREE WITH YOUR OWN STATEMENT �”
the two statements are not at all contradictory and are two of my statement Ive ben saying since day 1
“�medical decisions SHOULDN�T (necessarily) be made based on anecdotal reports by one doctor with promise that data will come later. �”
Absolutly true . do you disagree? I don’t think anyone does
“if you think following one doctor�s anecdotal report IS REASONABLE ( and I DON�T DISAGREE as I made clear over 2 months ago and dozens of times since).”
Absolutely true. do you disagree? I dont think anyone does.
to sum up:
A. If a doctor thinks a certain treatment will help. He should prescribe that treatment. (second statement above)
B. Just because one doctor claims success doesnt mean all doctors must follow it. (first stament above)
Ive been saying this over and over and over and over
what if any of the above are you disagreeing with?
” Both the recent studies we have debated in the last few posts”
I havent debated any study. you must have me confused with someone else. True I pointed out numerous errors and oversights you made but I’m not debating any study., just trying to help you understand them.
“they were not a cross-section of society.”
no they are not. so?
“They were THEN �randomized�.”
Yes, As I pointed out to you.
“so that is why they were not a random group ”
No they were not a random group, I believe they were all healthcare workers.
“were not self-distancing by the definition of the study”
If youre self distancing why do you need HCQ to prevent you from getting Covid. Who would you get it from?
“In a climate where the opponents of President Trump”
why does the Lancet care about Trump?
and aderaba they retracted! could you imagine Trump retracting anything he’s ever said
anyay this is all a side show
My main point is :
to sum up:
A. If a doctor thinks a certain treatment will help. He should prescribe that treatment. (second statement above)
B. Just because one doctor claims success doesn’t mean all doctors must follow it. (first stament above
which if any of these do you disagree with ?