Every bocher in yeshiva needs to know where he is holding and where everyone else in yeshiva is holding. Its part of life. He needs to know who he can trust to say ofer a shach. One person says over a shach and i can trust he read it right while someone else can read it and a assume he read it wrong. He also needs to know when is he ready to argue on achronim eother for pshat and even to pasken. Some people do not know how to think straight and they cannot trust themselves. Some bocherim in a yeshiva have the authority to just say a pshat is wrong and the bocherim on a lower level should just except it even if they can’t understand why. So everyone needs to know where everyone else is holding. And its not gava just like your rov is not a bal gava for thinking he knows enough to pasken your shalois.
Menu