Reply To: Biden Bringing in 11 Million Illegal Immigrants to Import More Democrat Votes

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Biden Bringing in 11 Million Illegal Immigrants to Import More Democrat Votes Reply To: Biden Bringing in 11 Million Illegal Immigrants to Import More Democrat Votes

#1949543

>> All Ethiopians undergo geirus misofek. Why not all Russians?

Because Ethiopians went through hundreds of years of having their version of Yehadut. Russians started coming in the 70s – 60 years after Soviets destroyed religious life, or just 30 for those from Lithuania and Latvia. A competent beit din can figure out who is Jewish or not by talking to their grandparents.

FYI, when the student movement for Soviet Jewry was starting in US in the 60s, both Rabbis and Israeli government were not eager. R Feinstein, R Teitz, Lubavitch Rebbe all called for a quiter approach to a different degree, partly being afraid of Soviets, partly to protect their own quiet efforts. R Soloveichik, when asked by students, consulted Israeli government, and also suggested restrained, but later changed his mind, when he realized that he based his halachik ruling on false advise from Israelis – he asked them “what is best for Soviet Jews”, and they replied “what is best for Israel” (as they hoped for diplomacy with USSR).

You seem to be making a similar logical error – making conclusions about a group of Jews not based on what they are, but how it immediately affects you.