Reply To: We, Yidden: G-d’s Chosen People!!

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee We, Yidden: G-d’s Chosen People!! Reply To: We, Yidden: G-d’s Chosen People!!

#1988461
Avram in MD
Participant

Avi K,

“1. More Torah learning is conducted in English and Hebrew.”

So? Being third doesn’t make something moribund.

“There is probably even more in French than in Yiddish.”

I think you may be unfamiliar with the Chasidic and Chareidi world. Spend some time in Brooklyn or certain parts of E”Y and you will hear a lot of Yiddish.

“2. Actually, it’s a German word, Knödel. It found its way into both English and Hebrew.”

At this point I can’t tell if this is all one big joke to you and you’re messing with me, or if you are blinded by sinas chinam to the point of cognitive dissonance. In a post earlier in this thread you used your favorite insult: calling Yiddish pidgin German. Then here you seemingly forget that. Of course Yiddish has a lot of German cognates. קניידלעך is Yiddish, and you said a Yiddish word. And it hasn’t really found its way into English. Most Americans call them matzo balls.

And if you say how is it sinas chinam – after all you’re just down on a language – but it is indeed just a language, and since you seem to like both German and Hebrew, it’s not the sounds of the language that bother you, it’s the speakers. Hundreds of thousands of your fellow Jews speak Yiddish, and may need to be reminded occasionally with a smile that other Jews may not. Maybe even remind them in Yiddish. You lose nothing, and increase achdus that way.