Reply To: Anti semitism poem

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Anti semitism poem Reply To: Anti semitism poem

#1991305

Listened to R A Leibowitz discussing Bava Kamma agada about R Eliezer Zeeri arrested by Resh Galuta for the hutzpah of wearing black shoes as mourning for Yerushalaim. R Eliezer puzzles him with the question – how much you pay for cutting down the palm tree. Resh G first offers just the cost of the tree. When asked – what about future dates, then he offers tree + future dates. Correct answer is in between and estimated using market value – ask for a price of a whole field with and without the tree, and damage is the difference.

R Leibowitz darshens: Resh Galuta = someone who is comfortable in Galut.

First price of just the tree – discounts the future produce (potential), sees only current sorry state of Yerushalaim and does not appreciate the miracles that grow there (see Avira above)

Second price – tree + dates – assumes as if all the dates are surely going to grow as if they are already here and, thus, can be charged for. This is over-optimism and not realistic.

Real price can be seen in the context of the value within the whole field – appreciate the potential but be realistic to what you have now.