Why is everyone so excited? The gemara can be read either way. That’s obvious from the context. I don’t care about the debate here about approach, because so many tong essays have been written on the topic that we are not going to change things based on a diyuk that is obviously inconclusive. It is of interest that you all feel threatened by this gemara. Because even how you read it, it’s still a kasha on you. And you don’t have a good teretz. So what that there is a kasha. A rayah it is not.
Menu