Reply To: Headlines

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Headlines Reply To: Headlines

#2135733
ubiquitin
Participant

No need to apologize
this whole thread was silly
I’m fine having fun with it
If in the process we learn something all the better

thanks for the mareh mekomos. Though I’m not sure what they add.
I don’t deny that a person being “shechted” r “l is very unpleasant. And even if one had to die, to die by “shechita” r”l is a terrible way to go, and when the Passuk uses such a gruesome term especially
at the hand of the Ribono shel olam; a pshat is warranted .

nonetheless, clearly they weren’t actually shechted as required to make food kosher.

Your complaint was “שחיטה is a הלכה משה מסנ”
This isnt true*. The word shechita is used lots of times in Tanach not referring to halachic shechita. (some examples provided there are more)
It is used lots of times in the Gemara not referring to halachic shechita especially when the shechita is passul for whaever reason . (example provided)
Another example (not in the beis hamikdash) ” Kam Rabbah shactei L’reb Zeira”

Furthermore in modern Hebrew it certainly includes any form of slaughter have a look at any Hebrew dictionary.
So even if we couldn’t find “=non-halachic examples of “shechita” in Tanach/shas (we found plenty) ok so YWN is using it in the modern hebrew sense . whats the problem?

* of course the exact method how to correctly shecht is haalcha l’moshe misinai, but that that is ALL the word means is not true.