Reply To: Question of an ignorant, closed-minded Lubavitcher

>>>MenachemShmei would never have quoted that because he would have realised that we would make a laughing-stock of him if he did.

It is correct that I wouldn’t bring this psak din. Not necessarily because I think the psak din is wrong, but mainly because I know that I wouldn’t care litvisher rabbanim paskened that the Rebbe isn’t Moshiach, so a psak din from one group of rabbanim isn’t much of a proof.

Regarding the rest of your problems with what the Rebbe said – I stand by what I wrote several times that it is improper to ask from excerpted quotes from long pilpulim. It takes many hours of learning a sefer and understanding the derech halimmud before asking “shturemdike kashyos.”