mdd1 I did not miss your point at all. You asked whether one “would prefer stam that all reshoim go straight to Gan Eiden even without being killed because they are Jewish?”
And I was commenting that there is nothing wrong with preferring that all Jewish resha’iim go to Gan Eden without being punished. But it’s not up to us to decide that, and the fact is that virtually no one goes to Gan Eden without being punished. Nonetheless, why would any of us “prefer” that resha’im go to Gehinnom? What would we gain by preferring that?