“Sorry, but I am not always online.”
You are clearly playing catch up. It is very noticeable how you keep changing your arguments. You simply never learnt the inyan, and now think that learning through Rav Moshe’s teshuvos makes you a mumchah. You do not even understand Rav Moshe’s teshuvos.
“There is nothing for ne to catch here. We got to the end. You aren’t saying anything.”
Incredible. You go on a long discursive regarding Rav Moshe’s teshuvos, clearly learning them for the first time, but claim that you have nothing to catch up! Because you simply do not know what you are talking about does not mean that I have not added to the conversation.
“You are the one who has not responded to anyone who really knew their stuff. Throughout this site, on a bunch of different threads, going back years. Now you are stuck with me.”
There is not one issue that I have not rebutted. You wouldn’t know it if I hit you over the head with it. Stay out of things you know nothing about.
“And, the point that Rav Elyashiv et all backed Reb Dovid, and nobody was able to get him to agree with their arguments, is a sore point to any gibberish you dream up. A sore point which you never addressed.”
It is not a sore point at all. First of all we do not know what was told to Rav Elyashiv. Second, Rav Elyashiv has nothing to do with Rav Dovid. Third Rav Dovid never wanted to speak to anyone about it, and his objection is regarding the original eruv. Furthermore, today it should be allowed according to what he clearly understood from his father regarding shishim ribo (as he stated regarding Chicago). Fourth, the stupidity does not stop. If Brooklyn was to lose most of it population, these anti eruvniks would still argue that Rav Moshe ossered. It is total absurdity, Rav Moshe did not know the statistics, and was lied to by a Brooklyn rav, but his psak stands. Total nonsense. Never mind, he did not issue a psak din barrur.