n0mesorah,
“I don’t see the purpose in this. It happens to be fun and more stimulating than most threads here.”
Oh but I thought that I don’t know what I am talking about. Please stop your narishkite, you do not know hwta you are talking about.
“1) You trust Rav Dovid’s statement about the Chicago Eruv (An eruv even more contentious than Brooklyn. I doubt you know or care about that). Yet, you reject Rav Dovid’s statements about the Brooklyn Eruv and his father’s knowledge of the statistics. And conveniently, you never mentioned Rav Dovid’s statement about the Los Angeles eruv.”
As usual a mishmash from a know nothing. As I said, I do not need Rav Dovid to learn a teshuvah, but for you and your ilk, I cite his opinion. No Chicago was not more contentious than Brooklyn (only by some Brisker, who most definitely would have a bigger problem with Brooklyn). I didn’t reject Rav Dovid’s statement regarding the Flatbush Eruv. I stated many times here that Rav Dovid was not referring to the current eruv only to the 1978 eruv. No, it is not my opinion regarding Rav Moshe and the Brooklyn statistics, it is a fact, he wrote incorrect numbers, and was clearly mislead, by an eino modeh beruvin. Oh and Rav Dovid agreed that his father would allow an eruv in LA (see the LA Guide Book). In fact besides for his gezeirah, there would be no reason for Rav Moshe to object to an eruv in LA. Those arguing against an eruv in LA in Rav Moshe’s name are simply ignoramuses, and do not begin to know his teshuvos.