Reply To: Hi I’m back 3.0

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Hi I’m back 3.0 Reply To: Hi I’m back 3.0

#2396044
yankel berel
Participant

@ddr

As far as I have heard from sources both from within and outside of habad the story is as follows:

The late rebbi of the habad hasidim was at the time waging a ferocious campaign for the change of Israeli Law .

Advocating for the insertion of the words giyur kahalacha in the text.

Pertaining to the type of conversion recognized by the israeli government , ensuring israeli gov rejection of Reform conversions made in the US.

The rebbi of habad decided to put a certain politician who was a member of the then government , into herem.

As a result of this p’s inaction in following the habad rebbi’s directives to either fix the law or resign.

One of the roshei yeshiva of torah vadaat , besides being an immense talmid haham , was an old hasid , still a mekurav from the rashab’s times.

He was appointed as RY by r shrage faivel Mendlowits in tora vada’at.

He was the author of ashkavte devei rebbi – a historical and scholarly sefer recounting the illness and the histalkut of the rashab and the beginning of the rayats’s leadership of the habad , who had a very privileged position in the rashabs household at the time and therefore a unique view of what was going on.

This RY also authored other sfarim , printing his hidushim on shas.

The rebbi of habad insisted that this talmid haham should join him in pronouncing the herem on this politician .

Apparently the rosh yeshiva did not think that the herem was justifiable al pi torah , so he did not join in this herem.

Whereafter the habad rebbi made some public remarks against the rosh yeshiva, whereafter the redifot against this rosh yashiva started ,

Those redifot had as a direct result that the RY died in his home.

After the RY’s petira, the rebbi of habad publicly disavowed any responsibility for the RY’s demise .

Ad Kan the story.

We should not use this story to throw mud.

We should however learn from this about the possibility within habad of someone implying that the leader of habad could be mistaken .

This RY implied it and ended up paying with his life.

The RY obviously held the rebbi from habad in high esteem .

Otherwise he would not be his hasid and attend all those public events with his rebbi.

Nevertheless , as a talmid haham who was higi’a lehora’a , in his opinion at least , said politician was not deserving to be put in herem .

He was not disrespectful.

He just held that his rebbi happened to be mistaken in this one instance , which is perfectly acceptable according to Jewish halacha and tradition.

So he abstained from the herem.
.
.