@HaKatan: Child, bless your heart (I mean that as the lowest form of insult). You’re utterly wrong, but it’s okay. I’ve spent enough time disproving your weak opinion and you know it.
@somejew – A spokesperson for Neturei Karta is not a valid source for anything. You know why.
@Non political – So Charedim can insist that the RZ Tzibbur follow their Rabbonim, their minhagim, etc.? No, two can play that game.
The reason for my requiring a court to issue a binding takana is simple: Charedim claim they are the only ones who truly represent Judaism. That’s a joke and utterly ridiculous, but that’s the claim. If that’s the case, then you need to show me you followed the Halachic process when deciding that Charedim should be except while everyone else isn’t. The most indisputable to do that is a Beis Din issuing a binding takana. Otherwisem, anything stated or published, whether proclamation or signed Pashkevillim – which everyone knows are an absolute joke and not worth the paper they are printed on – are simply written responsa to be considered but not binding in any manner since we have good reason for such, and there is no excuse for no service. It’s really that simple.