Reply To: dealing with Jews with aveiros

some> such a person, regardless of tochucheh, hatrueh, or any o’nes (like tinik shenishbu), it is forbidden to have rachmunos on or to be dan lekaf zchis

Look, there is no reason to have an argument between you and me. We can’t convince each other. I brought you evidence from R Moshe, who clearly had this rachmonus. So did R Ruderman from other evidence from the same sefer. And there are way more. So, to have a productive argument, please bring where R Moshe has an opinion aligning with you, and then we can discuss how we understand the differences.

> Those, one would need to check if their mistaken psak stems from fraudulent “rabbis” that they follow innocently or from an ideology of rejection of Chazal. … informing them and seeing if they indeed correct their mistaken ways

So, please read R Soloveitchik and inform me where he is incorrect. And note that he clearly had differences with his cousin R Moshe, but they were not calling each other “frauds” and had love and respect for each other. Again, please explain how you can call someone fraud when R Moshe did not