Joseph your attempt as distinguishing acceptance from resepct is creative, but misguided. In fact R. Schachter and other non-chareidi rabbanim are not respected, much less accepted. The proof of that is that he is not even allowed “in the room” much less given a seat “at the table” when the c hareidi “greats” convene to dsicuss issues of communal importance. The non-chareidi viewpoint is not even allowed to be voiced at such gatherings, are not considered at all, and are rejected by default. i think the events of a Agudah convention about fifteen years ago sums it up. One year, R. Sherer z”l expended tremendous effort to invite the modern Orthodox rabbis of Young Israel to the convention. There is no doubt that his motives were pure and genuine. In light of his efforts and out of respect for everything R. Sherer stood for, R. Hershel Schachter accepted the invitation and told R. Sherer that he would attend the Saturday evening keynote address. Ever the gentleman, R. Sherer reserved a front row seat for the Rosh Kolel of RIETS. I don’t remmeber who it was, but upon R. Schachter being seated either R. Gifter or R. Svei ver loudly and publicy stood up and walked out saying he would not return until [a very humiliated] R. Schachter left. You talk about respect. I’m lookng for basic human decency.
Menu