Home › Forums › YWN Main Site & Coffee Room Issues › Respect for other posters comments › Reply To: Respect for other posters comments
lesschumras:
I believe Joseph’s point is that we may be better off without “unprecednted numbers to live a kollel life”, since those who do learn can not reach their full potential while not in poverty (one of the 48). Good point by Cantoresq that without the struggle, we do not have the proper perspective on learning.
This is a valid argument, even though there are many Gedolim that would argue. (especially in E”Y, where funding is the only reason why the Charaidim are in politics.)
It is very possible that Rav Miller would agree, so Joseph is consistent. It does not bode well for Joseph’s view of Lakewood, though.