Reply To: R’ Shloimele Z”L

Home Forums Music R’ Shloimele Z”L Reply To: R’ Shloimele Z”L

#646676
rabbiofberlin
Participant

feivel- you are correct in saying that i should not judge the ones who dismiss Shlomo carlebach, so i will not cal lthem small minded people.

to cherrybim- your question shows your -forgive me- ignorance “what has shlomo carlebach for the klal?” Apart from his wonderful music, he broguht back thousands of people to yiddishkeit and he did it all virtually single handedly.

As far as being rejected by others- the Lubavitcher rebbe zz’l was rejected by the same Roshei yeshiva you pledge allegiance to. And Rav Kook – oy vavoy- he is ‘chutz lamachaneh”. so, just because a certain part of the klal rejects you does not mean that your shittah is wrong.Just ask the baal shem tov.

I am not sure what you mean by “my way of thinking” so I have no way of answering that. And-of course- I am delighted that the legend of Shlomo carlebach continues to grow, this tells you something. I also have no clue what yo umean by those closest to him are not part of the frenzy- all his talmidim are as enthusiastically following him as ever before.

Lastly, to be “motzi shem ra’ (his kiruv method would put him into prison…etc)without actual proof is truly out of bounds.