I think that is a good idea
but before I do:
You are right, I stand corrected. However I do still think charliehall’s general position can be maintained, albeit with a ‘loophole’ due to shas had’chak and not l’chatchila, as I have demonstrated.
The difference between l’chatchila and a shas d’chak is a very big difference in many respects and is hardly a “loophole”