Home › Forums › Kashruth › Cholov Stam › Reply To: Cholov Stam
So if you have a specific and particular individual cow that has had ths surgery and this particular cow dies within a year, then Rav Belsky paskens that it still is not treif?
Even if he paskens like that (and I do not know either way, that he does or does not) would all other Rabbonim agree with him?
If any Rav would disagree and paskens such a cow would be treif, then it would seem to me that someone who holds by their Rav who paskens, that such a cow is treif, then that person, if he drinks only C’Y’…..Would not be simply “following a chumra”, since he does not know, if the C’S’ milk from the cow that he might right now be drinking could be from, such a cow.
He would be keeping kosher, as paskened, by his Rav.