Reply To: Tznius in front of Non Jews

Home Forums Controversial Topics Tznius in front of Non Jews Reply To: Tznius in front of Non Jews

#694622
gavra_at_work
Participant

What happened to Siman Beis in shulchan aruch?

I have been asking myself the same question since yesterday when Chossan uncovered an apparent contradiction in Shulchan Aruch.

On one hand, a person must dress with Tznius. MB says this includes socks (at least when they did not wear pants).

On the other hand, a person can read (and be Yotze) Kriyas Shema bare-chested. Tefilla, the MB says, requires additional Kavod (Omed L’Fnei Hamelech) and a shirt. No mention of socks, etc.

Again, the key word in Siman Beis is “L’Olam”. Ask your LOR for actual practice.

However:

Simin Beis is based off (BY there) a Gemorah in Shabbos 118B:

??”? ???? ???? ?? ??? ????? ???? ????? ?????

Seems like this was a Hanhaga that R’ Yosi did that he was M’Shabach himself for it, and the Tur/SA suggests we do the same as well.

Also see Rashi on the Gemorah there.