Of course,in most cities/towns,it’s as Sac said –more about your personal befriending style.
But in certain parts of New York,it is possible to stand out in a way that’s uncomfortable.I don’t mind shopping in Boro Park and being asked if I’m from Crown Heights(maybe bec.my sheitel was being done and I wore a snood?),but on a regular basis ,I’d mind being conspicuous.