Reply To: Why don't jews have dogs? It is clear in the gemara and shulchan aruch that

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee Why don't jews have dogs? It is clear in the gemara and shulchan aruch that Reply To: Why don't jews have dogs? It is clear in the gemara and shulchan aruch that

#770438
nishtdayngesheft
Participant

Shedready,

Do you have a dog?

Do you have a car?

You say “the shulchan aurach say you can walk your dog with a leash in a risish horabim on shobbos and it is not considered carrying.” Once we get past all the misspellings and garbled language, can you cite the where? (Other than saying you saw it 0n the web.)

You also say that there were 33 million deaths for 250 million cars.

By that stat, after almost 8 years, everyone in the US should be dead. Obviously, your “stats” are entirely made up.

And I love how you quote yourself as a basis for statistics.

There are a myriad of reasons why people do not have a dog. There is no mitzvah, or chiyuv to have a dog. There are alot of halachic issues one would have to deal with that can well be a disincentive to have a dog. Besides the mess and the cost associated with them.

Your most brilliant dissertation values dogs greater than humans (Where you mention pets that have gone into fires when humans wouldn’t). Perhaps in your case that is correct. And we know that there was a very evil philosophy that held them same. But most civilzed people do not feel that way. And it certainly is not the Torah way. (Torah, is the guide that jews live by. In case you have not heard of it before)