HIE: so set me straight. Rav Bess claims that Rav Feinstein says not to eat the fish, I trust him. Rav Roth was matir 18 years ago as were many other Poskim who today asser. Do you know what Rav Roth holds today? If there are “many more” I would very much like to hear about them. I have been asking for names for weeks now and no one has been able to supply any. If you have been following my conversation with Daas Yochid, my personal opinion is that they should be mutar, but I have not found that the Gedolei HaPoskim agree. If you or someone else can prove otherwise it would be wonderful.
Menu