To summarize, it has been established here that:
- Cholov Yisroel is mandated in halacha by Shulchan Aruch
- Reb Moshe paskened there is a heter to rely on the American government to establish Cholov Yisroel
- Reb Moshe stated this heter is only in force Bshas Hadchak
- Reb Moshe stated, even yet, a Baal Nefesh would not rely on this heter
Questions:
gavra_at_work, How can one disregard a kula that specifically doesn’t exist except under specified conditions? And keeping other mitzvos does not exclude keeping this one. Should we not strongly encourage others to keep this mitzvah in Shulchan Aruch?
Jothar, How do non-psak anecdotes of Reb Dovid negate a psak?
Clarifications:
gavra_at_work, Can you elucidate who Rav Bick was, his position, and how America became his “assra”?
Anyone, What are “yad zorim” (in a Sefer perhaps)?