yichusdik — “My question was and is about the havoh aminoh of those who say that a hechsher should be about the animal, food, shechita, preparation only, and not about other elements which obviously mean a great deal to R’ Finkel.”
The hechsher still is about the animal, food, shechita, etc. — except they won’t give it if they feel you are a “bad neighbor.” That is different then actively giving a hechsher based on other criteria.
Health — I LOVE your idea of similar measures being taken against stores selling cigarettes.