Reply To: We can't win

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee We can't win Reply To: We can't win


Ok. We don’t need to snipe at each other.

We both know that the aguna problem is extremely tragic, and there is really no solution besides actually coercing the guy. And that is precisely what was happening here.

If you think you could not actually beat someone, I understand that. But let’s agree that the gemara says to beat him, and that it’s basically the right thing to do.