Rabbiofberlin. Hungarian and Galitzianer Jews who generally follow the same halachic patterns do not require females to daven plus many other mitzvos that they don’t emphasize at all. Generally the Polish chasidim did require females to daven at least brochos, krias shema and shemonei esrei, as I cited from the Tur, who states that halacho specifically concerning shemonei esrei, that women have a chiyuv. And as I stated, the Bach and Beis Yosef agree. Polish Jews who paskined like the Rav shulchan orech before ww2 now almost all paskin from the mishne brura. The Rambam, Rif, and Semag all hold that tefila is a d’ureisoh. Exactly what to say was instituted by the anshei keneses hagedolo. The machloikes between the Mogen Avrohom and others is on that basis. Everybody agrees that prayer itself is a mitzvas asei shelo hazman gromo and that females have a chiyuv. Mogen Avrohom says that since the exact method of prayer is miderabonon, females are potur from davening the official shemonei esrei, while everybody else says that since the concept of tefiloh is a d’ureisoh females have a chiyuv in the rabonon liturgy too. Hungarian and Galitzianer Jews who are generally lax in halochos concerning women accept that women don’t have to daven at all. ???? ?????? ????? ??????? ???? ?????? ????? ???? ???? ??? ??? ???? ???? . This is the eaxct loshon of the mechaber.
Menu