Reply To: Why do we judge each other?

The other writer was told he is wrong in two possible ways: 1) if he’s davening loud during shmonah esrei and 2) that he’s davening in a MO minyan. He wrote his thread b/c he was bothered by the fact that people were talking, and was told he doesn’t belong in a MO minyan (if I understood correctly). There is no shaichus in my opinion. People talk in yeshivish minyanim as well as MO ones. Instead of advising him to leave the minyan if people were disseminating ideas that are k’neged hatorah (which I would do), he was advised to leave after complaining people were talking.