“For the more learned, knowing what is Biblical and what is rabbinic is part of the beauty of Shabbos.”
That’s very nice to discuss with your chavrusa. But to put it on a public forum where anyone can read it is inapropriate.
Totally incorrect, as I pointed out earlier in the thread.
Discussing Torah by definition is L’Hagdilo, and by definition serves a purpose (As per the Pesukim of at the end of Shemini, discussing worms is Torah, and that is part of the purpose).
observanteen: From your post earlier, it seems like this is your “first contact” with the outside world. I’m normally not the sort to suggest that you go back into your hole in the ground (or other defensive system). However, in this case, that really may be what is best for you and your Yiddishkeit, as you don’t seem prepared for the “outside”, even from other frum Yidden.
Others (I think DHM) have mentioned that the difference between Charaidi & not is that Charadim ignore the outside and try to not expose to anything outside, and not try to prepare for the outside. It is very difficult to be outside if you have not been prepared. Think of it as a cold day. Some parents keep their children indoors, and others send them to play in the snow with a warm coat. If a child wants to go outside but doesn’t have that coat, they will be cold, CV.
I wish you only the best, Simchos & Bracha.