Sam2 -“Health: Ain Zu Darka Shel Torah. You cannot come with a conclusion in mind and re-work sources to fit that conclusion.”
Actually I’m quite shocked at your post. As a Bocher I wouldn’t expect such Chutzpah from you, like I get from some other posters!
“You have to have proofs that there is no Chiyuv to be Mekarev. You cannot just assume that you are right and that there must be another proof out there somewhere.”
I’ve posted these proofs above. It’s says clearly -Mefurishe Diyuk that you don’t have a Chiyuv to Mekarev anyone. I’m sorry that you’re too lazy to look it up!
The only thing I possibly conceded to was that I learned P’shat- the reason there is no Chiyuv was because they aren’t Bechlal Arvous, but if you give me another reason why there is no Chiyuv, I’ll accept this statement of -that they are Bechlal Arvous!