Reply To: Lights on Shabbos and Thanking Someone for Doing an Aveirah on Your Behalf

Home › Forums › Bais Medrash › Lights on Shabbos and Thanking Someone for Doing an Aveirah on Your Behalf › Reply To: Lights on Shabbos and Thanking Someone for Doing an Aveirah on Your Behalf

December 7, 2011 4:20 pm at 4:20 pm #840948
Sam2
Participant

To sort of agree with nitpicker, 20 years ago Jothar’s Rabbi would have been correct. I think most people have lost Ne’emanus on this issue. It is not for us to judge whether she did it as a Malitz Yosher or not (we certainly hope she did), but unless we know for a fact that she did I wouldn’t encourage it.