PBA: Of course not. I am self-aware enough to know what I know and there are very few cases where I am confident enough to argue on Poskim like that. I would almost never Pasken like this without running it by someone far more knowledgeable that myself to begin with. Here, I don’t have the burden of P’sak on me so I can learn how I think the Emes is without being scared of being wrong. I think my entire explanation here was Amittah Shel Torah. Would I be confident enough in that to Pasken like it if asked an actual Shaila? I can’t honestly say that until I’m asked L’ma’aseh, but this may be one of the very few (and honestly, there are very few) cases where I’m confident in what I know to Pasken like this. (Of course, I’m always more confident in my Shittos until I need to actually Pasken. Paskening is quite a scary thing, that’s for sure.)
Menu