Sam2 -“Health: The opinion of the Rishon(im) who say that Chinuch is on the kid is very minority and is very Dachuk (to say the least) from many Gemaros. Just because people can make good Lomdus out of it does not make it a Shittah that has Halachic relevance at all.”
Maybe you should read the post carefully before you comment.
Here it is – “Some people say the Chiyuv of Chinuch is a D’rabbonon on the Kid themselves.”
Acc. to this Shitta this obviously is the Halacha. Why are you making it sound that the Shitta doesn’t hold it Halacha L’masseh?