Reply To: Should Someone Who Is Considering Murder…

Home Forums Controversial Topics Should Someone Who Is Considering Murder… Reply To: Should Someone Who Is Considering Murder…

#879834
Chulent
Member

The Chasam Sofer says IF there were extenuating circumstances (i.e. mental illness) that prompted the suicide, then we do not treat it as a halachic suicide. The CS does not exclude the possibility of some cases falling under the halachic penalties prescribed for a suicide.