Reply To: Shlomo Carelbach

Home Forums Music Shlomo Carelbach Reply To: Shlomo Carelbach

#895727
rabbiofberlin
Participant

feif un: the most egregious thing you wrote comes at the end: “he encouraged others to do so as well”. Do you have a scintilla of evidence on that? This is pure rechilus (worse than loshon horah). Secodly, you write: “”he encouraged mixed dancing” ,This is absolutely false and again, pure rechilus. And what is the “chet’ of performing with non-Jewish singers? Bob dylan is JEWISH, by the way.

To say ‘the things he did with women is well known” is more rechilus. I am absolutely astounded at what you wrote.

About the only thing that you can hang your hat on is that “he used to hug and kiss women he didn’t know” He did do that and he was criticized for it, although he had a good reason (for another time).

The fact is that he was responsible, single handedly, for thousands of baalei teshuva (many of which I know personally), he revolutionized jewish music and today, his music (kabbolos shabbos and more) is sung by tens of thousands of jews all over the world- and “shaar haneginah’ is right next to ‘shaar hateshuva”.

His influence on jewish life and people in the latter half of the twentieth century is beyond measure and his influence will continue for generations.