There are a few things that are clear:
= = = = = = = = = =
What my previous approach was, and why I now believe it was wrong:
I now believe that this was the wrong approach, for the following reasons:
= = = = = = = = = = = = = =
yekke2–
You said you are a kid, which I assume means you are in yeshiva. Can you find any rov who thinks this is yashrus, or even muttar?
vochindik–
I can neither respect nor disrespect unnamed poskim.
Furthermore, what you are now saying is very different from your original post.
Which of the above two opinions are you asking me to respect?