Home › Forums › Controversial Topics › Giyoress or Not? › Reply To: Giyoress or Not?
Not exactly, Popa. As I suggested, even if we had such statistics, I don’t think they’d be very useful. Anyone reading our respective posts should be able to tell we disagree on a lot more than the feasibility of measuring gerim frumness.
Health, you don’t explain why your view is correct, despite the fact that knowing what all the mitzvos are is not a prerequisite for accepting the mitzvos. Both Rambam and S’A say that we teach them a few mitzvos and convert them. Ideally, gerim would know everything, and I’m sure most know everything they need to know, but if they have some misunderstanding or lack of knowledge about a particular mitzvah that doesn’t mean they didn’t accept the mitzvos.
Dolphina, I agree! If it were up to me, this thread would be deleted. This thread isn’t any less problematic than others that have been deleted.