mdd -“Quite frankly, I am tired of writing the same thing again and again.
And quite frankly, I am tired of reading your same Naarishkeit again & again!
“Da’as Yoichid, it clear from the Gemorah and Rishonim and Achronim that if the Goyim have a fair and reasonable ta’anah on the conduct of the Yidden it is Chillul HaShem.”
So what’s the analogy? Do you consider Not going to the army a Taanah that is fair and reasonable? I don’t and even the guy who started the Medina didn’t (Ben -Gurion). If you say he isn’t around anymore and we the Zionists don’t like his agreements -I’ll say fine – go start your own Medina somewhere like Uganda and only allow Charedim in your Medina that will follow your rules and any rule you decide to make whether it’s a whim or not.